Consider These Tips Before Considering Multiple Recruiting Agencies


Recently, I received a call from a distraught friend, who had just received an angry phone call from a recruiter. The recruiter had recently submitted my friend for a job through his staffing agency. The hiring manager responded that my friend was already in consideration through a competing agency. The recruiter was upset with my friend for not mentioning that he had already been submitted for the job. My friend, on the other hand, had no idea that he had already been submitted; or that two agencies would be working on the same job.

Tips to Consider When Working with Multiple Recruiting Agencies

At first glance, working with multiple staffing agencies seems to be the best way to maximize your chances of getting a job. By leveraging the connections, clients and jobs available through each, you end up with the greatest number of possible job opportunities. . . right?

Not always.

Know that being submitted twice may get you blacklisted

With certain companies, if the same candidate is submitted twice, the system will kick them out of the process entirely. Being submitted twice will not help your odds.

Try to avoid applying directly with a company and also through a staffing agency

Generally, if you have already applied through the company’s system, the company will not consider you as a candidate through a staffing agency.

  • Ask the recruiter if you will be considered if you have already applied through the company’s website. If they say yes, you can agree to be submitted.
  • Often, applying for a direct hire job through a recruiter is a great way to get your resume to the top of the stack – recruiters have direct access to hiring managers.

Ask the recruiter to consult you before submitting you for a role

Politely mention that you are working with multiple agencies and ask that the recruiter contact you for your approval prior to submitting you for a role.

  • In some cases, if you’re working with a recruiter and a similar role comes up that matches your job preferences, they may submit you and let you know afterwards.
  • However, you’ll want to review the job description prior to submittal to ensure you haven’t already been submitted.

Keep detailed records of all jobs you are submitted for

 Include the name of the agency, contact information for the recruiter, a description of the job, the client (if the job is not company confidential), the location of the job, the pay rate agreed to, the date you were submitted, and the date you were told you’d hear back.

Compare the new job opportunity to your list to ensure you haven’t already been submitted for the role. 

When a recruiter asks you about a job that sounds similar to a role you’ve discussed with another recruit, consult your list to see if you’ve already been submitted. Be honest with the recruiter about other opportunities you’ve been submitted for.

Remember that two job postings for the same role may not be identical

Recruiters create their own job postings, selecting key points from the client’s original job posting.

  • If you’re not sure if the job is the same, send the job description to the recruiter so they can review it.
  • If necessary, reach out to the first recruiter for more details before allowing the second recruiter to submit you. If they’ll release it to you, the name of the hiring manager is a good way to be sure.

Sign a right to represent agreement if requested

Sometimes, if recruiters know that multiple agencies are working on the same role, they’ll ask you to sign an agreement stating that you’re working with them on this position. This may also protect you if agencies submit your resume without your knowledge or consent.

  • “Bad” recruiters will submit your resume from a job board; and contact you only if an interview is requested. Submitting a candidate without their consent is not condoned by reputable staffing agencies.
  • If you’ve find out you’ve been submitted for a job by an agency you are not working with, you can contact the agency to request they withdraw your resume.

If two agencies contact you about the same job simultaneously, choose the agency that is the best fit

Each agency has its core competencies. Consider the following points:

  • Which firm has a stronger relationship with the client?
  • Which agency is a better match – does one agency typically staff jobs in this field; while this seems to be a “one-off” for the other firm?
  • The amount of time the recruiter spends with you and the level of detail they explain about the job.
  • Your previous experiences with each firm.

What has been your experience working with multiple agencies? Has it worked for you or not? Do you have additional advice to our job seekers on using employment agencies.

Jenni Chelenyak About Jenni Chelenyak

Jenni currently works with Adecco’s global Information Management team as a Business SME on the Candidate Management Programme - Social Media. She’s been with Adecco’s Professional Staffing division since 2010 and held roles in on-boarding and compliance, client account management and technical recruiting. In her free time, she enjoys traveling, spending time with family and friends, yoga and working with an animal rescue group.

Speak Your Mind